THE ANALYSIS OF STUDENTS LEARNING DIFFICULTIES IN READING COMPREHENSION
A CASE STUDY AT SMP NEGERI 3 KOMBI
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53682/soculijrccsscli.v3i4.11645Keywords:
Learning Difficulties, Reading Comprehension, Reading Difficulties, English Language LearningAbstract
Reading is one of the most used activities in English Language Learning ELL however many students struggle with reading skill in English classroom The present study aims at investigating the learning difficulties faced by students in reading text and the factors contributing to the learning difficulties The study conducted at SMP Negeri 3 Kombi employs qualitative method with case study design Eight 9th< sup> grade students are chosen as the sample of the study using purposive sampling Data collected from documentation and interview are analyzed through the 3 steps of qualitative data analysis namely data condensation data display and drawing and verifying conclusion The findings showed that 9th< sup> grade students at SMP Negeri 3 Kombi faced learning difficulties in reading recount text The learning difficulties they faced are vocabulary 55 making inference 45 determining main idea and finding detailed information 35 Factors such as limited vocabulary fluency familiarity with the subject matter and ineffective reading strategies contribute significantly to students reading difficulties Other factors such as weak verbal reasoning level of difficulty and information retention also contribute to the reading difficulties faced by the students This study suggests that teachers need to use various strategies to tackle the reading difficulties faced by the students < p>
References
Alderson J C 2010 Assessing Reading Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Al Jarrah H Ismail N S B 2018 Reading comprehension difficulties among EFL learners in higher learning institutions International Journal of English Linguistics 8 7 32 41 https: doi org 10 5539 ijel v8n7p32
Amendum S J Conradi K Hiebert E 2018 Does text complexity matter in the elementary grades? A research synthesis of text difficulty and elementary students reading fluency and comprehension Educational Psychology Review 30 121 151
Anderson R C Spiro R J Anderson M C 1978 Schemata as scaffolding for the representation of information in connected discourse American Educational Research Journal 15 3 433 440 https: doi org 10 3102 00028312015003433
Andries F Hammp P Rombepajung P Lengkoan F 2019 November The Application of Special Self Made Word Card for Vocabulary Teaching Particularly Irregular Verbs In International Conference on Social Science 2019 ICSS 2019 pp 969 971 Atlantis Press https: doi org 10 2991 icss 19 2019 47
Anthony E M 2022 Reading Comprehension Strategies: A Narrative Review Development in Language Studies 2 2 1 11
Arikunto S 2010 Prosedur Penelitian Suatu Pendekatan Praktik Jakarta: Rineka Cipta
Bahmani R Farvardin M T 2017 Effects of Different Text Difficulty Levels on EFL Learners Foreign Language Reading Anxiety and Reading Comprehension Reading in a foreign language 29 2 185 202
Baiti I U Sofa E M 2023 Indonesian and Egyptian EFL university students difficulties in reading comprehension Erudita: Journal of English Language Teaching 3 1 81 92 https: doi org 10 28918 erudita v3i1 7029
Balqis M N 2022 Students Difficulties in Reading Comprehension English LAnguage Study and TEaching 3 1 18 24
Banditvilai C 2020 The effectiveness of reading strategies on reading comprehension International Journal of Social Science and Humanity 10 2 46 50
Bowen G A 2009 Document analysis as a qualitative research method Qualitative research journal 9 2 27 40
Brooks G Clenton J Fraser S 2023 Exploring the Importance of vocabulary for English as an additional language learners reading comprehension In EAL Research for the Classroom pp 35 58 Routledge
Chen S C Chen K T 2015 The use of EFL reading strategies among high school students in Taiwan The reading matrix 15 2 156 166 Retrieved from https: readingmatrix com files 13 pdf
Chiang M H 2016 Effects of varying text difficulty levels on second language L2 reading attitudes and reading comprehension Journal of Research in Reading 39 4 448 468
Chin C S 2002 Context semantic mapping and word lists: Effectiveness on EFL learners vocabulary growth English Teaching 57 4 245 266
Chou P T M 2011 The effects of vocabulary knowledge and background knowledge on reading comprehension of Taiwanese EFL students Electronic Journal of Foreign Language Teaching 8 1
Daneman M Tardif T 2016 Working memory and reading skill re examined In Attention and performance XII pp 491 508 Routledge
Dila P W 2024 An Analysis of Students Difficulties in Reading Comprehension At The First Semester of The Tenth Grade Students of SMK Negeri 1 Natar in The Academic Year of 2023 2024 Doctoral dissertation UIN Raden Intan Lampung
Fadhilla N Chandra C Wijanarko T 2024 Analisis Kesulitan Membaca Pemahaman Siswa Kelas IV Sekolah Dasar Sulit Air TSAQOFAH 4 4 3172 3180 https: doi org 10 58578 tsaqofah v4i4 3217
Fahriany 2014 Schema theory in reading class IJEE Indonesian Journal of English Education 1 1 17 21 http: dx doi org 10 19166 dil v5i1 6567
Frans S A Ani Y Wijaya Y A 2023 Kemampuan Membaca Pemahaman Siswa Sekolah Dasar [Reading Comprehension Skills of Elementary School Students] Diligentia: Journal of Theology and Christian Education 5 1 54 68
Grabe W Stoller F L 2013 Teaching and researching reading Routledge
Graham L Bellert A 2005 Reading comprehension difficulties experienced by students with learning disabilities Australian Journal of Learning Difficulties 10 2 71 78 https: doi org 10 1080 19404150509546791
Gundrum D A 2022 Uniqbu journal of social sciences ujss vol 3 no 2 3 2 https: doi org 10 31219 osf io hwrjp
Harvey S Goudvis A 2007 Strategies that work: Teaching comprehension for understanding and engagement Stenhouse publishers
Hossain K I 2024 Reviewing the role of culture in English language learning: Challenges and opportunities for educators Social Sciences Humanities Open 9 100781 https: doi org 10 1016 j ssaho 2023 100781
Intan S 2022 An Analysis of Students Difficulties in Comprehending English Reading Exercises at The Eleventh Grade of MA Ma arif Nu 02 Sidorejo in The Academic Year 2021 2022 Doctoral dissertation UIN Raden Intan Lampung
Jamali Kivi P Namaziandost E Fakhri Alamdari E Ryafikovna Saenko N Inga Arias M Fuster Guill n D Nasirin C 2021 The comparative effects of teacher versus peer scaffolding on EFL learners incidental vocabulary learning and reading comprehension: A socio cultural perspective Journal of psycholinguistic research 50 1031 1047
Jaroslawska A J Gathercole S E Allen R J Holmes J 2016 Following instructions from working memory: Why does action at encoding and recall help? Memory Cognition 44 1183 1191
Jin T Jiang Y Gu M M Chen J 2022 Their encouragement makes me feel more confident : Exploring peer effects on learner engagement in collaborative reading of academic texts Journal of English for Academic Purposes 60 101177 https: doi org 10 1016 j jeap 2022 101177
Joh J Schallert D L 2014 How conception of task influences approaches to reading: A study of Korean college students recalling an English text TESOL Quarterly 48 4 715 737
Kim Y S G Quinn J M Petscher Y 2021 What is text reading fluency and is it a predictor or an outcome of reading comprehension? A longitudinal investigation Developmental psychology 57 5 718
Klauda S L Guthrie J T 2008 Relationships of three components of reading fluency to reading comprehension Journal of Educational psychology 100 2 310
K ko lu H 2013 Improving reading skills through effective reading strategies Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences 70 709 714
Larasati D 2019 An Analysis of Difficulties in Comprehending English Reading Text at the Eleventh Grade Students of MA LAB UIN SU Medan Doctoral dissertation Universitas Islam Negeri Sumatera Utara
Lee S A 2022 The Philosophy of ESL: A Literature Analysis on the State of English as a Foreign Language Open Access Library Journal 9 10 1 10 https: doi org 10 4236 oalib 1109350
Lei S A Rhinehart P J Howard H A Cho J K 2010 Strategies for improving reading comprehension among college students Reading Improvement 47 1 30 43
Lestari R P Fitriani S S Erdiana N 2017 Reading comprehension difficulties encountered by senior high school EFL students Research in English and Education Journal 2 2 110 118
Lestari T Muljanto S Hamzah A 2020 An Analysis of Students Difficulties in Reading Comprehension English Education and Applied Linguistics Journal EEAL Journal 3 1 43 49 http: dx doi org 10 31980 eealjournal v3i1 1095
Liando N V F Tatipang D P Tamboto G Poluan M Manuas M 2022 Pictures as a learning media in teaching vocabulary Jurnal Ilmiah Universitas Batanghari Jambi 22 3 1944 1949 http: dx doi org 10 33087 jiubj v22i3 2832
Lubis S N Dwinata E 2024 ANALYSIS OF THE SEVENTH GRADE STUDENTS DIFFICULTIES FACTOR IN READING COMPREHENSION AT SMPN 1 CAMPURDARAT Journal of English Teaching and Linguistics Studies JET Li 6 1 1 9
Marlinton M Syahri I Mayasari S 2023 The Efficacy of Task Based Learning and Learning Motivation on Student s Reading Comprehension: A Wholistic Study Elsya: Journal of English Language Studies 5 2 250 269 https: doi org 10 31849 elsya v5i2 14082
Maru M G Paranduk R Tuerah J 2021 Readability Level of English Reading Text Used in The Era of Pandemic Syntax Literate: Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia 6 7 http: dx doi org 10 36418 syntaxliterate v6i7 3557
Masduqi H 2016 Integrating receptive skills and productive skills into a reading lesson In Proceeding of the International Conference on Teacher Training and Education No 1 pp 507 511
Miles M B Huberman A M Saldana J 2014 Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook 3rd edition Sage Publications Inc
Moghadam S H Zainal Z Ghaderpour M 2012 A review on the important role of vocabulary knowledge in reading comprehension performance Procedia Social and Behavioural Sciences 66 555 563 https: doi org 10 1016 j sbspro 2012 11 300
Nanda D W Azmy K 2020 Poor reading comprehension issue in EFL classroom among Indonesian secondary school students: Scrutinizing the causes impacts and possible solutions Englisia: Journal of Language Education and Humanities 8 1 12 24 http: dx doi org 10 22373 ej v8i1 6771
Nurjanah R L 2018 The analysis on students difficulties in doing reading comprehension final test Metathesis: journal of English language literature and teaching 2 2 253 264
Nurmalasari N Haryudin A 2021 The Students Difficulties in Learning Reading PROJECT Professional Journal of English Education 4 1 29 34 https: doi org 10 22460 project v4i1 p29 34
Nuttall C 2000 Teaching reading skills in a foreign language Oxford: Macmillan
Oakhill J Cain K Elbro C 2014 Understanding and teaching reading comprehension: A handbook Routledge
Pabur H E Ismail Ali M I Tatipang D P 2023 The Use of Literature in English as a Foreign Language Teaching and Learning Process: The Relationship and Suggested Techniques to be Used in EFL Classrooms Edumaspul: Jurnal Pendidikan 7 2 2660 2670 https: doi org 10 33487 edumaspul v7i2 6159
Peng P Barnes M Wang C Wang W Li S Swanson H L Tao S 2018 A meta analysis on the relation between reading and working memory Psychological bulletin 144 1 48
Pranoto E S A 2021 AN ANALYSIS OF STUDENTS DIFFICULTIES IN READING COMPREHENSION THROUGH GOOGLE DOCS EDUTAMA
Rahmani M Sadeghi K 2011 Effects of note taking training on reading comprehension and recall Reading 11 2 116 128
Ramadhianti A Somba S 2023 Reading comprehension difficulties in Indonesian EFL students Journal of English Language Teaching and Literature JELTL 6 1 1 11 https: doi org 10 47080 jeltl v6i1 2477
Rasinski T 2014 Fluency matters International electronic Journal of elementary education 7 1 3 12 Retrieved from https: iejee com index php IEJEE article view 60
Sadiku L M 2015 The importance of four skills reading speaking writing listening in a lesson hour European Journal of Language and Literature 1 1 29 31 https: doi org 10 26417 ejls v1i1 p29 31
Safitri S D and Budiasih 2023 Students Difficulties In Reading Comprehension At The Eighth Grade Of SMP N 2 Weru In Academic Year 2022 2023 Skripsi thesis UIN RADEN MAS SAID Accessed from https: eprints iain surakarta ac id id eprint 6748
Sapitri D Novia F 2020 AN ANALYSIS OF STUDENTS DIFFICULTIES IN COMPREHENDING NARRATIVE TEXT Language and Education Journal 5 2 103 112
Saraswati N K R Dambayana P E Pratiwi N P A 2021 An analysis of students reading comprehension difficulties of eighth grade students at SMP Negeri 4 Tegalalang Jurnal IKA 19 1 34 45
Sarica G N Cavus N 2008 Web Based English Language Learning Presented at International Educational Technology Conference 2008 Retrieved September 10 2024 from https: www learntechlib org p 62190
Septia N W Indrawati I Juriana J Rudini R 2022 An analysis of students difficulties in reading comprehension EEdJ: English Education Journal 2 1 11 22 https: doi org 10 32923 eedj v2i1 2519
Sharifi S Rezaei S 2018 The effectiveness of working memory training on reading difficulties among students with reading disorder Iranian Journal of learning and memory 1 1 43 54
Siddiek A G Alfaki I M 2013 The role of background knowledge in enhancing reading comprehension World Journal of English Language 3 4
Smith R Snow P Serry T Hammond L 2021 The role of background knowledge in reading comprehension: A critical review Reading Psychology 42 3 214 240
Snow Cetherine 2002 Reading For Understanding: Toward a Researcher and Development Program in Reading Comprehension New York: RAND
Sulung Y Y Tuerah I J 2021 The Effect of Choral Reading Strategy on Teaching Students Reading Comprehension SoCul: International Journal of Research in Social Cultural Issues 1 01 21 29 https: doi org 10 53682 soculijrccsscli v1i01 1696
Torppa M Vasalampi K Eklund K Sulkunen S Niemi P 2020 Reading comprehension difficulty is often distinct from difficulty in reading fluency and accompanied with problems in motivation and school well being Educational Psychology 40 1 62 81 https: doi org 10 1080 01443410 2019 1670334
Trassi A P Oliveira K L D In cio A L M 2019 Reading comprehension learning strategies and verbal reasoning: possible relationships Psico USF 24 4 615 624
Westwood P 2008 What teachers need to know about reading and writing difficulties ACER Press
Yin R K 2017 Case study research and applications: Design and methods Sage publications