I am well aware of it Yet my Students have to Learn in comfort way: Translanguaging as Mediated English Language Pedagogy

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.53682/eclue.v13i2.4598

Keywords:

Translanguaging, ELT Context, Mediated Pedagogy, Language Learning Pedagogy

Abstract

This study examines the practice of translanguaging in English language learning in one of the secondary schools in Manado which is a multilingual environment with the use of the local language of Manado Indonesian and English The main objective of the study was to understand teachers beliefs and their translanguaging practices as language mediation strategies that support concept understanding social interaction and student motivation The method used was a case study with three English teachers as participants collecting data through interviews observations and documentation then analyzed thematically The findings suggest that translanguaging serves as a cultural and cognitive bridge that facilitates students to understand the material more deeply and strengthen their linguistic identity Despite concerns about reduced exposure to English due to the use of local languages and Indonesian teachers use translanguaging strategically to balance learning The main obstacles found are the limitations of school policies and teacher training that support the implementation of translanguaging In addition translanguaging has been shown to increase students motivation to learn and active participation This research recommends the development of teacher education and training policies that are responsive to language diversity as well as the development of a curriculum that accommodates translanguaging as a legitimate learning strategy This study makes an important contribution to the development of inclusive and contextual English language pedagogy in multilingual classrooms in Indonesia< p>

References

Agustin S Wahyudi R 2024 Indonesian university students practices and perspectives on translanguaging Journal on English as a Foreign Language 14 1 238 260 https: doi org 10 23971 JEFL V14I1 7817

Bonacina Pugh F Da Costa Cabral I Huang J 2021 Translanguaging in education Language Teaching 54 4 439 471 https: doi org 10 1017 S0261444821000173

Cenoz J Gorter D 2022 Pedagogical Translanguaging and Its Application to Language Classes RELC Journal 53 2 342 354 https: doi org 10 1177 00336882221082751

Chaisiri P 2022 The Potential of Translanguaging for English Language Teaching in Thailand Journal of Studies in the English Language 17 2 56 80 https: doi org 10 14456 JSEL 2022 6

Chicherina N V Strelkova S Y 2023 Translanguaging in English Language Teaching: Perceptions of Teachers and Students Education Sciences 2023 Vol 13 Page 86 13 1 86 https: doi org 10 3390 EDUCSCI13010086

Emilia E Hamied F A 2022 Translanguaging Practices In a Tertiary EFL Context In Indonesia Teflin Journal 33 1 47 74 https: doi org 10 15639 TEFLINJOURNAL V33I1 47 74

Garc a O Wei L 2014 The Translanguaging Turn and Its Impact In Translanguaging Palgrave Pivot London https: doi org 10 1057 9781137385765_3

Goodman B Tastanbek S 2020 Making the Shift From a Codeswitching to a Translanguaging Lens in English Language Teacher Education TESOL Quarterly https: doi org 10 1002 TESQ 571

Imre Heltai J 2023 Translanguaging as a rhizomatic multiplicity International Journal of Multilingualism 20 3 1016 1030 https: doi org 10 1080 14790718 2021 1926465

Jimenez D D Tang S Rivera H H Chang H Zhu Y 2025 A Narrative Literature Review of Classroom Observation Protocols in Bilingual Education: Bridging Theoretical Frameworks for Practical Implementation Journal of Latinos and Education 1 22 https: doi org 10 1080 15348431 2025 2566097

Liando N V F dallyono R Tatipang D P Lengkoan F 2023 Among English Indonesian and local language: Translanguaging practices in an Indonesian EFL classroom Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics 13 1 204 216 https: doi org 10 17509 IJAL V13I1 58270

Liando N V F Tatipang D P 2022 English or Indonesian Language? Parents Perception Toward Children s Second Language Learning Context Jurnal Lingua Idea 13 1 61 75 https: doi org 10 20884 1 JLI 2022 13 1 5749

Liando N V F Tatipang D P Lengkoan F 2022 A Study of Translanguaging Practices in an EFL Classroom in Indonesian Context: A Multilingual Concept Research and Innovation in Language Learning 5 2 167 185 https: doi org 10 33603 RILL V5I2 6986

Liu Y Fang F 2022 Translanguaging Theory and Practice: How Stakeholders Perceive Translanguaging as a Practical Theory of Language RELC Journal 53 2 391 399 https: doi org 10 1177 0033688220939222

Llanes Cots J M 2022 Measuring the impact of translanguaging in TESOL: a plurilingual approach to ESP International Journal of Multilingualism 19 4 523 538 https: doi org 10 1080 14790718 2020 1753749

Madkur A Friska Y Lisnawati L 2022 Translanguaging Pedagogy in ELT Practices: Experiences of Teachers in Indonesian Pesantren based Schools Voices of English Language Education Society 6 1 130 143 https: doi org 10 29408 veles v6i1 5136

Mahdi S 2023 Effective Communication in Learning: Teacher Strategies and Their Impact on Student Learning Outcomes International Journal of Linguistics Communication and Broadcasting 1 4 26 30 https: doi org 10 46336 IJLCB V1I4 26

Margana Rasman 2021 Translanguaging and minoritized language maintenance: Lessons from Indonesia 3L: Language Linguistics Literature 27 2 https: doi org 10 17576 3L 2021 2702 01

Miles M Huberman M Saldana J 2014 Qualitative Data Analysis H Salmon ed ; 3rd ed Sage Publications https: doi org https: doi org 10 1080 0140528790010406

Mitchell G Chojimah N Nurhayani I 2022 Directions for Indonesian Language Policy in Education: Towards A Translingual Perspective NOBEL: Journal of Literature and Language Teaching 13 2 271 292 https: doi org 10 15642 NOBEL 2022 13 2 271 292

Nursanti R R 2021 Classroom Strategies through Translanguaging for Multilingualism Students English Learning Innovation 2 1 17 27 https: doi org 10 22219 ENGLIE V2I1 14653

Ossa Parra M Proctor C P 2021 Translanguaging to Understand Language TESOL Quarterly 55 3 766 794 https: doi org 10 1002 TESQ 3011

Peng J Mansor N S Ang L H Kasim Z M 2022 Visualising the Knowledge Domain of Linguistic Landscape Research: A Scientometric Review 1994 2021 World Journal of English Language 12 5 340 355 https: doi org 10 5430 WJEL V12N5P340

Pesch A M 2021 They call me anneanne translanguaging as a theoretical and pedagogical challenge and opportunity in the kindergarten context in Norway Acta Borealia 38 1 23 42 https: doi org 10 1080 08003831 2021 1911200

Putrawan G E Mahpul Sinaga T Poh S K Dekhnich O V 2022 Beliefs about Multilingualism with Respect to Translanguaging: A Survey among Pre Service EFL Teachers in Indonesia Integration of Education 26 4 756 770 https: doi org 10 15507 1991 9468 109 026 202204 756 770

Rahayu S S Rochsantiningsih D Sumardi S 2023 Teacher Practices in Translanguaging and Trans semiotizing pedagogy in ELT classrooms: An Indonesian Case Study VELES Voices of English Language Education Society 7 2 345 354 https: doi org 10 29408 VELES V7I2 21304

Raja F D Suparno Ngadiso 2022 Teachers attitude towards translanguaging practice and its implication in Indonesian EFL classroom Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics 11 3 567 576 https: doi org 10 17509 IJAL V11I3 38371

Rajendram S 2023 The cognitive conceptual planning organizational affective social and linguistic discursive affordances of translanguaging Applied Linguistics Review 14 5 1185 1218 https: doi org 10 1515 APPLIREV 2020 0075

Rubinstein C V 2020 Translanguaging as Practice and as Outcome: Bridging across Educational Milieus through a Collaborative Service Learning Project Translanguaging as Transformation: The Collaborative Construction of New Linguistic Realities 234 250 https: doi org 10 21832 9781788928052 019

Rubinstein C V 2024 Translanguaging as Practice and as Outcome: Translanguaging as Transformation 234 250 https: doi org 10 2307 JJ 22730468 21

Sakhiyya Z Martin Anatias N 2023 Reviving the language at risk: a social semiotic analysis of the linguistic landscape of three cities in Indonesia International Journal of Multilingualism 20 2 290 307 https: doi org 10 1080 14790718 2020 1850737

Setya Ningrum A C Sahiruddin S 2023 Translanguaging Practices in Tertiary Context EFL Classrooms in Indonesia Culturalistics: Journal of Cultural Literary and Linguistic Studies 7 2 12 22 https: doi org 10 14710 CA V7I2 20688

Setyaningrum R W Setiawan S Anam S 2022 Translanguaging as a Scaffolded Practice in a Primary School Content and Language Integrated Learning Context During the COVID 19 Pandemic European Journal of Educational Research 11 4 2043 2055 https: doi org 10 12973 EU JER 11 4 2043

Sugiharto S 2024 Translanguaging as a Counter Narrative in EFL Practice EDULANGUE 6 2 138 149 https: doi org 10 20414 EDULANGUE V6I2 9138

Susanto G Suparmi Rusiandi A Noviya H 2024 Indonesian language policy and perspectives on its implementation in promoting Bahasa Indonesia as an international language Cogent Arts and Humanities 11 1 https: doi org 10 1080 23311983 2024 2364511

Sutrisno D B 2023 Multilingualism Translanguaging: A Review of Translanguaging Practices in the Linguistically Diverse Indonesian EFL Classrooms Journal of Languages and Language Teaching 11 3 547 554 https: doi org 10 33394 JOLLT V11I3 8265

Triastuti A Nurkamto J Sumardi S 2023 Translanguaging Pedagogies in an ESP Course: A Case in Indonesia VELES Voices of English Language Education Society 7 3 527 541 https: doi org 10 29408 VELES V7I3 23912

Umam A H Sugiharto S Manara C 2023 Translingual practice in remote EFL tertiary education: How multilingual speakers create translanguaging spaces Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics 13 2 258 269 https: doi org 10 17509 IJAL V13I2 63065

Wangdi T Shimray R 2022 Thai EFL School Students Perceptions of Using L1 in English Language Classrooms Journal of Asia TEFL 19 1 257 264 https: doi org 10 18823 ASIATEFL 2022 19 1 17 257

Wei L 2022 Translanguaging as method Research Methods in Applied Linguistics 1 3 https: doi org 10 1016 J RMAL 2022 100026

Wei L Garc a O 2022 Not a First Language but One Repertoire: Translanguaging as a Decolonizing Project RELC Journal 53 2 313 324 https: doi org 10 1177 00336882221092841

Xin S Ping W Qin Y 2024 Twenty years development of translanguaging: a bibliometric analysis International Journal of Multilingualism 21 1 209 235 https: doi org 10 1080 14790718 2021 2007933

Yasar Yuzlu M Dikilitas K 2022 Translanguaging in the development of EFL learners foreign language skills in Turkish context Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching 16 2 176 190 https: doi org 10 1080 17501229 2021 1892698

Yin R K 2018 Case Study Research and Applications Design and Methods 6th ed SAGE Publications Inc

Downloads

Published

2025-10-06

How to Cite

I am well aware of it Yet my Students have to Learn in comfort way: Translanguaging as Mediated English Language Pedagogy . (2025). Journal of English Culture, Language, Literature and Education, 13(2), 277 296. https://doi.org/10.53682/eclue.v13i2.4598